Villaflor was a seven-time All-MIAA selection with two first-team and two second-team selections in singles along with two first-team picks in doubles and one second-team honors in doubles. She led Emporia State to their first MIAA Team Championship and a trip to the NCAA Sweet 16 in 2007. She is the school record holder with a 59-7 singles record in dual play and went 60-16 in doubles. She was a three-time ITA Central Region champion in doubles with two different partners and was an academic all-district performer.