Stueve was a three-time First-Team All-American and the leading scorer in MIAA history with 2,403 points and ranks fourth in MIAA history with 1,040 rebounds. She is the only Lady Hornet and one of just three MIAA players all-time with 2,000 points and 1,000 rebounds in a career. Her 777 points as a sophomore are the second most in a single season in MIAA history while her 674 points as a senior ranks sixth in the league and makes her the only player to appear in the top ten twice for the conference. She holds the Emporia State career record with 301 made three-pointers. She led the Lady Hornets to the Elite Eight as a sophomore after being named the MIAA Freshman of the Year in 2005. She was a second-team Academic All-American as a senior.